subversive opinion time
i really wish i hadn’t gone to the unity rally today.
now hear me out. it’s not because i don’t support the cause. in fact, it’s exactly the opposite. i wish i hadn’t gone on campus to the unity rally today because in doing so, i missed all of the counter-protest. i did not get to see, hear, or have any proof that the westboro baptist protesters actually were there when they said they were. i did not get to stand against them or voice my opinion or even just be in the presence of the protest. frankly, i am very unhappy with the way the school handled the whole ordeal.
i understand the intent behind the “unity rally.” i get their excuses. “let’s not give them publicity.” “let’s show them that we are united together.” “let’s not get hurt by their words.” and i also get the meaning behind them. “let’s keep the emotional teenagers from doing something stupid that’s going to get them hurt or us sued.” of course, no one’s going to put that last reason on record, but i’m pretty sure we all recognize that it’s there. and i mean, i like my classmates and all, but there were just too many people proposing we throw eggs for me to be sure that had we actually had a counter-protest, nothing bad like that would have happened. i get it. i really do.
but i also think that it’s completely wrong for them to do everything in their power to prevent us from acknowledging the existence of the protesters. i’ll be honest, i really didn’t care about the dancing. i didn’t go to see that. i went to be a part of the movement against the hateful speech of the westboro baptist church.
my plan was to get there around 7:30, see how the posters on the front of the school were going, see the beginning of the rally, and then cut out to go see the actual protest. anyone who thought that the fact that we were going to be sequestered in the quad meant that there were going to be no protesters outside the school was obviously not thinking hard enough, because i hear there was a very sizable counter-protest. of course, i was not allowed anywhere near that. from the moment i hit the corner of finch and stevens creek, i was shuttled into the quad and told to stay put. not only was i not allowed out of the quad, i was also not allowed near the gate because i might (heaven forbid) see the protesters. the main gate in the quad had about 10 teachers guarding it for most of the morning, yelling at students to get away if anyone tried to look. same with every exit. see, i had been under the impression that the unity rally was, you know, a rally, not a lockdown.
in the protest, there was no violence. there was some shouting, but the speakers blasting in the quad made sure that i wasn’t going to be hearing that. all i wanted to do was see the protest. i didn’t need to go talk to them. i didn’t need to yell at them. i just wanted to see them. and our dear admin made it their personal goal to make sure i did nothing of the sort. i cannot help but think that’s wrong.
my friend and i went to every single exit onto finch to find a way out. as soon as the dancing started we knew that the “support the cause” part was effectively over and we wanted to find some other way to be part of the counter-protest. we finally got off campus a couple minutes later thanks to a lenient teacher near the student parking lot, but by the time we got anywhere near the protest the westboro baptist protesters had moved on.
the only way i got to see the protesters was through the pictures other people took. i find that appalling. i came to participate in a counter-protest, or even just SEE a counter-protest, and all i got was to see some pictures of signs i’ve already seen on the internet. there was something very real, very important, and very unique going on in front of our school, and because i made the mistake of taking part in the school’s idea of a good plan, i missed all of it.
i should have waited until 8:00am and come over with my mom (who, by the way, actually got to see the protesters), then joined the counter-protests with the rest of the members of our community. there are pictures circulating of students with signs and protesters, and you can bet that they didn’t go to the rally. either from cupertino or other schools, they decided not to bother with the school-sanctioned event and go with the community instead. they were the smart ones.
now there are some of you here on tumblr who believed whole-heartedly in the whole “unity rally” thing. and that’s fine. it’s a perfectly valid idea. what is not okay with me is the fact that by coming at 7:30am to the finch avenue area, i was forced to participate in this rally. i was given no choice as to how i wanted to voice my support for the anti-westboro protests. you can argue for your rally to the death, but it’s not acceptable for me to have no other choice but to participate in it when i did not want to.
i wanted to see that protest. i had a right to see that protest. and yet, i didn’t get to. how is that a success?